In the waning months of the year 1828 Scotland was scandalised by the sordid revelations that accompanied the apprehension and trial of Burke and Hare for the notorious West Port murders in Edinburgh. In the midst of the trial a less well-celebrated murder came to the public’s attention. The suspect in this new case was also an Irishman. His downfall was the venue for his ultimate crime; on board the Toward Castle steam boat from which there was no escape. John Stuart was a 32 year-old unemployed blacksmith who had been living in the Newcastle area and decided to return to his native Ireland with his wife Catherine Stuart Wright. He made his way across the country and took passage in the Eclipse steam boat at the Broomielaw, bound for Belfast. Foul weather was encountered in the Kilbrannan Sound and the boat put in to Campbeltown to wait until the weather improved. There was some...